browser icon
You are using an insecure version of your web browser. Please update your browser!
Using an outdated browser makes your computer unsafe. For a safer, faster, more enjoyable user experience, please update your browser today or try a newer browser.

A New York State of Murder

Posted by on July 24, 2008

Forgotten News book coverIf you like reading about life in the 19th century, crime, New York City, then you should seek out Jack Finney’s “Forgotten News: The Crime of the Century and Other Lost Stories.” If you like all three subjects, that’s an order.

It’s risky for me to write about “Forgotten News,” because then I have to pick it up, and then I have to read a sentence, which leads to another sentence, and then an hour has passed and I haven’t written a line and although it makes me feel guilty, I don’t want to stop. That’s how good a book it is.

There, with Finney by your side, he’ll reveal stories that are at times familiar, strange, uncanny, and just plain weird.

None of these you’d see nowadays. Maybe we’re more self-conscious. Maybe there are too many cameras, and we fear looking foolish. Few people did back in the 19th century, and that’s something I miss.

“Forgotten News” is a scrapbook, with long and short stories and a few pages in between of short-shorts, all lavishly illustrated with contemporary woodcuts from “The New York Times,” “Harper’s Weekly,” “Leslie’s” and others.

Harvey BurdellMost of the book is taken up with two stories: “The Crime of the Century,” the murder in 1857 of Dr. Harvey Burdell in his office/home on Bond Street in lower Manhattan, and the sinking of the Central America, a steamship that went down off the coast of Florida. Both stories were extensively reported; at a time when newspapers were the sole medium of transmitting information, they had to provide in-depth, detailed stories.

While the Central America story is a fine piece of reportage, I’m much more enamored of the Burdell case, and here Finney walks us through the story with the assurance of an accomplished raconteur. He shows us Saratoga Springs, where the confirmed bachelor met Emma Cunningham, a thirtyish widow with five children and an eye for marriage. He documents Emma’s determined path into the doctor’s life, moving into rented rooms in his three-story house (starting in the attic and moving down, through her machinations, to his second-floor suite); her bizarre machinations to eliminate any female rivals; her attempts to entrap him into marriage, first by pregnancy (miscarriage), then by a lawsuit for breach of promise.

When all that failed, she introduced into the household another boarder, John J. Eckel, a tall, bearded man, stronger than Dr. Burdell and at least ten years younger. For reasons known only to Burdell, he felt threatened. An acquaintance of his said the doctor told him that “there was some damned cut-throat fellow about the house, and he did not like him.”

In the weeks leading up to his death, he would tell many people about his fears. But he did nothing. Finney looks at several of the good doctor’s actions and conclude that, at heart, he was a weak fellow, full of bluster but not of brawn.

Which is why he was found, in his office, strangled and stabbed.

The day after the murder, the grand jury, composed of men yanked from the street and meeting in Dr. Burdell’s parlor, accused Emma Cunningham of murder. The murder and trial was reported extensively in the papers, complete with verbatim transcripts of all the testimony, and while Mrs. Cunningham was found not guilty, the story did not end there.

Along the way, Finney expands on the various incidents, major and minor, and places us there. Through it all, we can feel his deep yearning for a time machine that would transport him there, where there seemed to be more time to spend with each other, and where there was always something interesting going on. Where the pope rides in a special train car lavishly carved in wood by Italian craftsmen, with the papal mitre on top. Where during the holidays, there are highjinks on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange. Where postal employees moving to a new building make it an elaborate, torchlit ceremony, a public spectacle.

Or, as Finney wrote in his foreword: “It was a wonderful varied time, the last century; and if this book can help you visit it with anything like as much pleasure as it’s held for me, then it was worth the three years I never dreamed it would take me. It was worth it anyway.”

Note: Copies of “Forgotten News” can be found at http://www.abebooks.com. Another book on the case, “Butchery on Bond Street,”can be bought at Amazon. The author also has a blog.

4 Responses to A New York State of Murder

  1. Benjamin Feldman

    thanks for including a link to my book in your review of Finney’s book ! Finney’s work was wonderful to read and impelled me to dig much further into the case, in primary sources, and to provide a definitive historical report of the case as well as crafting a socio-political framework for what I believe to be a watershed in American gender politics.

    Ben Feldman

  2. Bill Peschel

    Thanks so much for your comments. Randy, “Time and Again” is a wonderful book, and that’s what led me back to “Forgotten News.” The photographs he found were really revealing of the time, wasn’t it?

  3. Randy Johnson

    I’ll have to get this one. The Finney book I always liked was Time and Again. I loved the way he wove the old photographs of the time into the story. The snap of Lady Liberty’s torch holding hand sitting there floored me the first time I read the book.

    Thanks for the review.

    Randy Johnson

  4. Patti Abbott

    What a terrific review. Thanks so much.